OnPay
Straightforward cloud payroll solution for small businesses with full-service payroll, automatic tax filing, HR tools, and benefits administration at a simple flat-rate monthly price.
Last updated: 2025-03-05
OnPay is a straightforward payroll and HR platform founded in 2007 in Atlanta, Georgia. It targets US small businesses with a single-plan pricing model — $40/month base plus $6 per person — that includes payroll, tax filing, and basic HR tools without tier-gating features behind more expensive plans.
Our Honest Take
OnPay's biggest strength is simplicity. Unlike Gusto's three-tier structure, OnPay offers one plan that includes everything: full-service payroll with automated tax filing, benefits administration, HR tools, and employee self-service. There's no decision fatigue about which plan to choose, and no discovering that the feature you need is locked behind a higher tier. The payroll engine is reliable — it handles federal, state, and local taxes, processes W-2s and 1099s, and supports multiple pay schedules. A free trial lets you test the system before committing, which Gusto doesn't offer.
The limitations are the flip side of that simplicity. OnPay doesn't include built-in time tracking — you'll need a separate tool or integration for that. The integration ecosystem is smaller than Gusto's or Rippling's, which can be a friction point if you're connecting multiple business tools. The platform is US-only for payroll, and its HR features (employee directory, document storage, basic onboarding) are functional but thin compared to a dedicated HRIS. OnPay works best when your needs are straightforward payroll and tax compliance, not comprehensive HR management.
OnPay is ideal for US small businesses under 50 employees that want reliable payroll with transparent pricing and no upsell pressure. It's particularly strong for businesses that tried doing payroll manually or through an accountant and want their first dedicated platform. Once you need time tracking, advanced HR, or international payroll, you'll outgrow it — but for its target audience, the value proposition is clear and honest.
Who This Is Best For
- US small businesses (5-50 employees) that want straightforward payroll with no tier complexity and predictable pricing
- First-time payroll buyers transitioning from manual processes or accountant-managed payroll to a self-service platform
- Price-sensitive teams that want one transparent plan rather than navigating Gusto's three-tier pricing to find the right fit
- Companies that want to try before buying — OnPay's free trial lets you test the full platform, which Gusto doesn't offer
- Businesses with simple HR needs that want employee self-service and document management alongside payroll without a separate HRIS
Who Should Look Elsewhere
- Companies that need time tracking integrated with payroll — Gusto's Plus plan includes this; OnPay requires a separate tool
- Growing companies (50+ employees) that will need advanced HR features — BambooHR or Rippling are better paths for scaling
- International businesses — OnPay is US-only; Deel or Remote.com handle global payroll
- Teams with complex integration needs — OnPay's ecosystem is smaller than Gusto's or Rippling's, which may limit connectivity with your existing tools
Overview
OnPay is a cloud-based payroll management platform founded in 2007 and headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia. The company has positioned itself as a straightforward alternative to more complex payroll solutions, targeting small-to-midsize businesses (SMBs) that need reliable payroll processing without excessive complexity or customization overhead. The platform handles core payroll functions including automatic tax filing, employee benefits administration, and HR tooling—all bundled under a simple flat-rate monthly pricing model.
What distinguishes OnPay from competitors is its commitment to simplicity combined with compliance coverage. The platform supports EEO/OFCCP compliance tracking and GDPR compliance features, addressing regulatory requirements that smaller organizations often struggle to manage independently. The addition of a mobile app, API access, and workflow automation reflects OnPay's effort to provide modern functionality while maintaining ease of use. With a 4.8/5 rating and a free trial option available, the platform appears to resonate with its target market, though it operates on a paid subscription model with no free tier.
OnPay's architecture emphasizes integration—HRIS integration capabilities and a reporting dashboard suggest the platform is designed to work within existing HR tech stacks rather than as a standalone monolith. This approach appeals to growing companies that have already invested in other HR tools and need payroll to fit seamlessly into their workflow.
Who Should Use OnPay?
-
Small to mid-sized businesses (10–500 employees) seeking an all-in-one payroll and HR solution without the complexity of enterprise platforms. Companies in this range typically benefit most from OnPay's simplified feature set and flat-rate pricing model.
-
Companies prioritizing compliance and automation in regulated industries or with multi-state operations. The EEO/OFCCP and GDPR compliance features are particularly valuable for organizations that need to demonstrate compliance readiness without hiring dedicated compliance staff.
-
Organizations with existing HR tech ecosystems that need a payroll tool capable of integrating via API and HRIS connections. OnPay works best when complementing tools like ATS or benefits platforms rather than replacing an entire HR infrastructure.
-
Businesses looking to reduce payroll processing overhead through workflow automation and automatic tax filing. Companies tired of manual tax calculations and quarterly reconciliation are OnPay's ideal fit.
The Bottom Line
OnPay delivers a focused, compliance-aware payroll solution designed explicitly for small businesses that want dependable processing without unnecessary complexity. Its flat-rate pricing removes guesswork from budgeting, and features like automated tax filing and workflow automation address genuine pain points for cash-strapped HR teams. The strong 4.8/5 rating and established 17-year track record suggest the platform reliably serves its niche.
However, prospective users should recognize the limited public information about pricing and feature depth—critical evaluation requires requesting a demo or trial. The platform's suitability ultimately depends on your team size, compliance requirements, and existing HR technology. OnPay is a solid choice for growing SMBs seeking straightforward payroll automation with compliance safeguards, though larger organizations or those requiring deep customization should evaluate alternatives.
OnPay Pricing
Standard
Full-service payroll, tax filing, HR tools
Contact vendor for current pricing.
UnverifiedOnPay Features
AI & Automation
Analytics
Compliance
Integrations
Mobile
OnPay Pros & Cons
Pros
- + Simple, transparent pricing ($40 base + $6/person)
- + Full-service payroll with tax filing
- + HR tools and benefits admin included
- + Excellent for small businesses under 50 employees
Cons
- - No time tracking built in
- - US-only payroll
- - Limited to smaller companies
- - Fewer integrations than Gusto or Rippling
How we evaluate tools
Our ratings combine verified user reviews from G2 and Capterra with hands-on feature analysis. Pricing is checked against official sources. We may earn a commission through affiliate links, but this never influences our rankings or recommendations. Read our full methodology.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does OnPay compare to Gusto?
Both cost $40/month base + $6/person at the entry level, but OnPay includes all features in one plan while Gusto gates features like time tracking and next-day direct deposit behind the $80/month Plus plan. OnPay offers a free trial; Gusto doesn't. Gusto has a more polished interface and broader integration ecosystem. Choose OnPay for simplicity; choose Gusto for polish and integrations.
Does OnPay include time tracking?
No. OnPay doesn't have built-in time tracking. You'll need a separate time tracking tool and can import hours into OnPay for payroll processing. This is one area where Gusto's Plus plan has an advantage, as it includes time tracking natively.
Is OnPay good for companies over 50 employees?
OnPay can technically handle larger companies, but its HR features are basic. Companies over 50 employees typically need more advanced onboarding, performance management, and reporting than OnPay provides. At that size, consider BambooHR or Rippling for a more comprehensive platform.
Does OnPay handle benefits administration?
Yes. OnPay includes benefits administration with its single plan — health insurance, 401k, and workers' comp. It partners with licensed brokers and can help set up benefits if you don't have existing plans. This is included at no additional cost beyond the base subscription.
OnPay Integrations
OnPay connects with 6 tools and platforms.
Communication
Productivity
Payroll
Company Info
- Company
- OnPay Inc.
- Founded
- 2007
- Headquarters
- Atlanta, GA, USA
- Deployment
- Cloud
Review Ratings
Featured Comparisons
Buying Guides
Get the Shortlist Spreadsheet
130 tools compared — ratings, pricing, and free plans in one CSV. Plus weekly updates.